Your master peaks at exactly 0 dBFS and the meter agrees, but the file clips after conversion to a streaming format. The meter was not wrong. It measured the samples, and the converter plays back a smooth wave that can go higher.
Samples are not the waveform
A digital file stores points. The converter in a playback device joins those points into a smooth continuous wave. When two neighbouring samples are both near full scale, the wave that passes through them can rise above both of them in between. That bump is an inter-sample peak. A normal peak meter only looks at the stored points and never sees it.
How much can it overshoot?
On typical loud, limited music it is often a fraction of a dB to around 2 dB. In contrived cases it can be higher. That is enough to push a decoder or a cheap converter into clipping, and it is exactly where lossy encoders (the kind streaming services use) can add a little extra level of their own.
How true peak is measured
The method in ITU-R BS.1770 is simple. Upsample the signal at least four times, then take the highest value of the result. The unit is dBTP. A true-peak limiter runs the same estimate before it applies gain, so the output stays under the ceiling on the reconstructed wave too.
What ceiling to use
- -1 dBTP is a common safe default for music going to streaming services.
- -2 dBTP makes sense for very loud masters, because lossy encoding adds more overshoot the harder the signal is pushed.
- Check each platform's current delivery guidance, because the numbers change.
Practical steps
- Put a true-peak limiter last in the chain and set its ceiling to -1 dBTP.
- Do not follow it with anything that changes level, including a "fix" gain plugin.
- Bounce, then reload the file and measure it again with a true-peak meter. Believe the measurement of the file, not the setting you typed.
- If you convert to a lossy format yourself, listen to the converted file once, at the loudest part.
The Grains Limiter estimates true peak by oversampling and shows loudness readouts next to the ceiling.
